From quick set up, to easy access, secure back ups, fast restoration, simple file sharing and synchronization theres a utility for all of your everyday tasks. Asustor, qnap, and synology introduce new nas units at ces 2020. I compared this software on likewise nas from synology and qnap below. Personally, i find the qnap software more userfriendly and more useable, insofar as. Qnap ts1685 vs synology ds3617xs battle of the nas behemoths. Aug 15, 2016 but then i get word synology is discontinuing the 3614 series for the 3617 series. While qnap s firstparty applications are somewhat limited when compared to synology s options, qnap units are designed to work with a large fleet of thirdparty applications. Jun 15, 2019 synology makes a lot of units and theyre confusingly named. Visit here for more information on choosing the correct hdd for your synology nas synology raid calculator offers you an estimate on the space utilization with various mixed hdd configurations and raid types.
Like the qnap software, synologys software is just as feature packed and theres simply way too much to cover in depth. Support for plex media player is one of the uppermost reasons why people buy network attached storages. Fast and reliable recovery delivered to keep running services, vms, and files instantly available. I run four larger synology nas units holding 120 tb of data. If you want raid5 then you would need to look at a software solution or proper raid card but then the synologyqnap is only software raid anyway. Have use buffalo terastations professionally, and there is a known issue with the controllers which send alerts if you have this configured indicating bad sectors on the drives, imminent failure and whatnot. When i originally looked into a nas device, i picked the qnap. I use a synology ds212j obviously for about 4 years. Comparison of synology diskstation ds216j and qnap ts228. Qnaps software provides more options, more room to tweak and tinker.
I just run the g8 headless and connect by rdp occasionally as needed. Qnap software isnt in a different league to synology, but the better hardware does make a difference when youre trying to do more intense tasks. Synology vs buffalo vs qnap data storage spiceworks. Likewise, qnap has spent years refining their nas operating system with qnap turbo station, or qts.
Sep 10, 2019 while qnaps firstparty applications are somewhat limited when compared to synologys options, qnap units are designed to work with a large fleet of thirdparty applications. Explore the extensive library of packages to meet your needs. If synology is mac, then qnap is most certainly windows and android. Qnaps ts251 dualdrive nas offers excellent readwrite performance, solid fault tolerance, and a sweet set of features to serve as a multimedia content storage starall at an affordable price. More direct attached options and therefore software like kodi and plex via hdmi on a qnap. I went with a qnap personally, because i like to mess with things just because i can. Sign in to myqnapcloud to securely access your remote qnap devices, manage your nas from anywhere, and share files easily. Afp performed better on the synology nas compared to qnap, but still lagged behind by between 5075 mbsec. Not to be a dick but if you want guaranteed support in a production environment, dont buy synology or qnap.
Im kind of fancying getting a qnap nas and using the drives i currently have in the hp. Sep, 2018 qnap software isnt in a different league to synology, but the better hardware does make a difference when youre trying to do more intense tasks. Compare synology diskstation nas ds218j 2bay 512mb ram and qnap desktop nas ts231p 2bay raid 1gb ram ds218j ibsy218j product page. The actual hdd size will be affected by the system partition and can vary between vendors, so the values calculated may differ from the actual results. However, qnap has recently released their vastly improved qvr pro and this is a great deal better. If you prefer to access your networkattached storage device from a smartphone, you should be familiar with the specific offerings of each brand. Aug 18, 2017 i have neither used drobo, nor synology. For expanding storage beyond the box, qnaps products support an iscsi initiator to build simple sans by attaching to iscsi targets. Straight away when you compare the specifications both in terms of hardware and software of a qnap nas versus a synology, you will immediately notice that you get much better cpus and ram options in the qnap, as well as it costing less. Synology takes a different approach by offering some models with expansion cabinets connected by. Synology and qnap both off great hardware, with both having worked on their software development to reach a strong solid os. The choice then was similar a qnap one of just about identical specs and price. Hp microserver nas but last time i powercycled it, the usb containing the os had become corrupted i suspect a problem with the os and it was a pita to get it going again.
Synology announced the 4bay ds420j nas at ces 2020, though the details of the unit have been public for a few months now. It uses the same qts management interface as qnaps other nas deviceswe like synologys dsm software a little more, but its largely a. Of course, in this qnap series, qnap makes a 16 bay and a 24 bay, and synology does not. Straight away when you compare the specifications both in terms of hardware and software of a qnap nas versus a synology, you will immediately notice that you get much better cpus and ram options in. Asustor, qnap, and synology introduce new nas units at ces. Comparison of synology diskstation ds416j and qnap ts431. Qnap is concentrating more on virtualization, while synology is focused on surveillance. Qnap vs synology customer support data storage spiceworks. I prefer synology because their software is very good, and is userfriendly. Mobile accessibility comparison all the recently released units from synology and qnap offer access to a range of mobile apps for ios, for android, and even for windows mobile. Synology is fine for those systems where you need support, but not live. Applied models the models of this series are not compatible with the latest version of dsm. If you have any further questions about qnap products or solutions, contact customer service through the service portal. My other devices which uses services provided by these nases never have an issue with synology, whether it is name resolution, ddns, dlna, smb or cloudsync features.
There is no avoiding the fact that the synology dsm and qnap qts software platform evolved and changes much, much faster than the hardware and even nas drives that are 12 years old will still support some of the latest and most powerful innovations available in. While qnaps firstparty applications are somewhat limited when compared to synologys options, qnap units are designed to work with a large fleet of thirdparty applications. Active backup centralizes backup tasks for vmware, hyperv, windows endpoints, office 365 and g suite to synology nas and lets you manage from one simple console. Discover new and convenient ways of using your nas with qnap utilities. For the software and user interface, i have had far less complaints with synology, where it just seems to work and is way more polished than qnap. Both software offerings are pretty much identical, so youll need to compare other features. One article i read compared synology to a mac and qnap to a linux box. As an online tech company, we do a lot of work online as well as local and we need places to store data. Which one is the best value between synology and qnap for. Here are our recommendations for most people looking to get in on the synology game at home. Both synology and qnap units will arrive with their own desktop user. Oct 23, 2017 make sure you test out the demo of synology dsm and qnap qts before you buy your nas be sure to test the software and nas operating system of the device you are considering before committing. Qnap ts1685 vs synology ds3617xs battle of the nas. Both synology and qnap are going to allow you to run tons of addon apps, like an itunes server, a download station, your own private cloud server, antivirus software, surveillance camera software, timemachine backups and a lot more.
Synology invests heavily in its firstparty software, meaning that diskstation manager the os on the unit to put it plainly will run all those 1st. Synology the beefy qnap tvsec880 delivers better performance under heavy workloads, while the elegant synology ds2015xs shines with useful tools. In these circumstances, reading emails becomes inconvenient, and the ip addresses you use will be recorded and may cause a potential threat to your privacy. Network attached storage nas has grown exceptionally popular in 2019, for a number of reasons. Im sure other people here can give you their insights. Software store get licenses for advanced features from our software store. Surveillance station live demo the intelligent surveillance and video management system that you can count on. However, the difference lies in the direction of their software development. The comparison table below makes it easier to choose the most fitting nas. Easily access your files from computers and mobile devices. The desktop settinginterface of dsm os shares relatively high semblance with apples macos while qnaps qts os can be compared to. However, qnap units will transcode your plex media server more efficiently than synology device. Discussion in nas systems and networked home and smb software started by msvirtualguy.
Free for everyone who would like to learn more about how to use qnap as your private cloud storage. The bad news is that you need a nas with a x86 so amd or modern intel architecture cpu in order to use this software. And of course, being among the best, both synology and qnap come with support for plex media server. At the time the synology was quite a bit faster 50% or so in real world tests. Aug 08, 2016 not to be a dick but if you want guaranteed support in a production environment, dont buy synology or qnap. In some areas, you may even require special software to use gmail. Synology is much better with qc of their software and are generally always ahead of qnap in new feature esfunctionality after a few years of tinkering with my qnap, i realized everything i needed it to do came with prebuild packages from the community. I reran the tests several times with both 4 gb and 8 gb sequential read write operations and the results were still pretty consistent, placing smb v3 above afp in general. The problem i have with synology is their os has become quite bloated and the hardware extremely underpowered for the price you have to pay for them.
Synology dsm versus qnap qts demos the fast way to choose. Jan 10, 2020 synology announced the 4bay ds420j nas at ces 2020, though the details of the unit have been public for a few months now. Sync your files securely between multiple computers, servers, and public clouds. Qmailagent centralize multiple email accounts in one app. Discussion in nas systems and networked home and smb software started by msvirtualguy, jun 15, 2017. Synology surveillance station is an allinone video management system. Qnap and synology are both excellent, and are the market leaders. There are also specialized utilities to assist with optimal management of virtualization environments and surveillance systems.
Ive used synology and theyre awesome, but not for production where you want a response in a guaranteed timeframe. Diskstation manager dsm is an intuitive webbased operating system for every synology nas, designed to help you manage your digital assets across home and office. For details, please refer to the product support status page. Qnap bundles optware which provides immediate access to a ton of software, including much newer versions of core binaries. It is based on the same realtek rtd1296 used by qnap in its ts230 unit. Synology takes a different approach by offering some models with expansion cabinets connected by either esata or infiniband cabl. Dell vs synology in terms of supportdell have enterprise support at a price that may cost the whole synology nas like 4 hour or next business day onsite response for up to 7 years while depending on your location, synology would more likely be. Which storage solution should i buy for personal home use. Hard to find and the only 3617 available doesnt have dual power. The sidebyside comparison of the devices specifications. Synology has a network only stance qnap has remote, audio inout, speakers, keyboard and mouse access. But then i get word synology is discontinuing the 3614 series for the 3617 series. I need to rebuild my storage backend i use for emby and other things as its currently a usb3 multidrive caddy connected to a j1900 itx board the machine its connected to is also my emby server.
Get licenses for advanced features from our software store. I found that the qnap solution is really a server that can run all types of virtual services. Yes, the qnap stays up and working reliably but then again so does the g8 microserver as did the n40ln54l i had before it. Sep 28, 2018 the problem i have with synology is their os has become quite bloated and the hardware extremely underpowered for the price you have to pay for them. Realizing the need for high security and privacy, qnap offers qmailagent an online email agent for qnap nas. Ive found that some things qnap is just better at doing, e. Which is fine except they seem to have stopped production on the 3614s all together. Compare synology diskstation nas ds218j qnap desktop nas ts.
The qnap tvs1271urp seems to have a lot of the same functionality as the 3614 series. I put in my own compatible drives, originally 2 x 1tb wd black, then 2 x 2tb wd red. Granted that synology has a nice looking gui for their firmware, but qnap is bound to catch up with their qts v4. Never used synology, so no opinion one way or another. For expanding storage beyond the box, qnap s products support an iscsi initiator to build simple sans by attaching to iscsi targets. The same money for a 2j gets you a quad core and 4gb expandable memory ram with qnap this sure as hell was the case last time i checked prices a few months ago. They are essentially the same price right now amazon and seem to have fairly similar specs.
After leaving this page, you can reach your last comparison under comparisons. There is no avoiding the fact that the synology dsm and qnap qts software platform evolved and changes much, much faster than the hardware and even nas drives that are 12 years old will still support some of the latest and most powerful innovations available in the latest firmware updates. Qnap offers slightly better hardware for the same price. With it, you can easily turn your nas into a fullyequipped network video recorder. First, the importance of our data at home with our family, to the phones that we carry on the commute, to the devices we use in everyday work create data constantly. Solved synology vs dell nas data storage spiceworks. For example, you can install unofficially supported software such as kodi, netflix as well as a large selection of qnap homebrew applications that were birthed on. Buy the perfect synology or qnap nas get it right the. It shares many of the features and functionality of the synology counterpart, but whereas the synology dsm software hides all the technical information and restricts actions to a more stable and controlled environment, qnap and qts given you the technical information far more readily. Synology or qnap everything you need to know nas compares. In theory usb3 should have a decent amount of bandwidth, in practice for whatever reason the caddy isnt much faster than usb2 and cannot handle random.
1088 1147 262 230 559 665 645 1202 186 38 558 465 1390 194 546 360 1203 207 98 12 456 941 82 502 1220 817 1279 345 1302 407 521 316 354 900 1028 762 345 460 1327 482